From the slapstick comedies of the 1950s to the kitchen-sink dramas of the 1960s, and the revival of rom-coms in the 2000s, the dog remains cinema’s most loyal supporting actor. It asks for no billing, negotiates no fee, but dictates the emotional truth of every romance it inhabits. The BFI, in its ongoing mission to preserve the complexities of British storytelling, has inadvertently preserved a simple truth: to understand how humans love on screen, watch how they treat the dog.
This trope finds its most heartbreaking expression in the BFI’s preservation of The Innocents (1961). While technically a ghost story, the film’s subtext is a twisted romance between the governess and her employer. The dog, Flora, becomes a victim of the psychological battle. As the romantic tension curdles into obsession, the dog’s fear and eventual silence mark the point where love turns into possession. The BFI’s notes on the film argue that the dog’s deteriorating relationship with the governess is the first, most reliable sign of her descent into madness. The BFI’s collection of British slapstick and Ealing Comedies offers a lighter take: the dog as the ultimate romantic saboteur . Think of The Ladykillers (1955). While not a romance, the dynamic between Professor Marcus and Mrs. Wilberforce is a bizarre courtship dance, constantly interrupted by her parrot and her dog. The dog doesn't facilitate love; it prevents it, barking at the wrong moments, chewing crucial evidence, and physically inserting itself between the two leads. bfi animal dog sex hit
In the BFI’s “British Screwball” list, the film The Horse’s Mouth (1958) features a scruffy terrier that has more screen chemistry with the female lead than the artist protagonist does. The BFI’s essay on the film notes that the dog’s constant interventions—stealing shoes, vomiting on rugs, demanding walks mid-kiss—act as a pressure valve. The audience laughs at the frustrated couple, but the dog’s presence also forces them to prove their commitment. If they can survive the dog, they can survive marriage. In this way, the animal becomes a trial by fur. No article on this topic would be complete without referencing a literal entry in the BFI’s National Archive: It Shouldn’t Happen to a Dog (1946), directed by Herbert Mason. This wartime romance, starring Alastair Sim and a bull terrier named “Bill,” is the ur-text for the dog-romance genre. From the slapstick comedies of the 1950s to