He isn't wrong. The English version of Kung Fu Hustle loses the specific musicality of the original language. However, unlike most foreign films, Kung Fu Hustle is a visual slapstick film. 70% of the comedy is visual—the eyes popping out of heads, the cartoonish running, the exaggerated falls.
If you are studying film or want to understand Stephen Chow’s true writing style, hunt down the subtitled English version. But be warned—the cultural references will fly over your head unless you know 1970s Hong Kong cinema. The "Dragon Dynasty" DVD Dub (A Lost Relic) Between the Sony dub and the raw subtitles lies a rare hybrid known as the Dragon Dynasty dub (released on a specific 2-disc DVD set in 2006). This is the holy grail for collectors. english version of kung fu hustle
Unlike the theatrical subtitles that match the dubbed script, these subtitles try to stay as close as possible to the original Cantonese. For years, fans debated a specific line in the film. When the Landlady yells at the Landlord, the Sony Dub says: "Why are you running? You look like a pregnant cow!" The literal subtitle says: "Why are you running? You look like a cow with a tumor!" He isn't wrong